Email Gluten-free is Life

Product Review: Yes! To Cookies

I received some complimentary samples of Yes! To Cookies cookies a couple of months back. I don’t like to “sit on” reviews for this long, but I don’t like to write negative reviews either. I have been thinking about the “right” way to write the review and now believe that I am ready.

Yes! To Cookies were born when a man was trying to create a cookie for his love who suffered from severe insulin dependent diabetes. Traditional cookies with starch & artificial sweeteners caused her blood sugars to rise. After many, many attempts, he came up with the perfect starch-free, sugar-free cookie that didn’t cause a rise in his love’s blood sugar. Some Yes! To Cookies facts from the site:

  • Zero Sugar
  • Zero Starch
  • Zero Gylcemic Index
  • Zero Digested Carbs
  • Zero Worries

Cocoa-Licious flavor: Erythritol, Cereal Fiber Psyllium*, Butter, Egg, Whey Protein Isolate, Cocoa Powder, Psyllium Husk, Organic Gum Acacia, Natural Vanilla flavor, Spices, Cellulose HP-SA, Sodium Bicarbonate, Rebaudioside A (as a sweetener) and Salt.

Strawberry-Banana Blitz flavor: Erythritol, Cereal Fiber Psyllium*, Butter, Egg, Whey Protein Isolate, Psyllium Husk, Organic Gum Acacia, Natural Strawberry, Banana and Vanilla flavors, CelluloseGum, Sodium Bicarbonate, Rebaudioside A (as a sweetener) and Salt.

I have to honest here, we did not care for these cookies at all. The strawberry-banana blitz tasted like bubble gum. The cocoa-licious tasted chemicaly. Jon, Lindsey & I all sampled both flavors & we all had the same opinion. I do want to point out that we don’t have to follow a sugar-free diet, so there may not be many options out there available that don’t raise the blood sugar, which is a big concern for diabetics.

Yes! To Cookies can be purchased on, a location near you or on the Yes! To Cookies website. They are available in mix form or premade.

Have you tried these cookies?

7 comments to Product Review: Yes! To Cookies

  • I just wanted to leave you a quick comment letting you know that I really enjoy reading your posts and this post has made your stock go up even more with me. While I completely understand that you don't want to give anyone in this small and help-centered community a "bad review" it is nice to hear someone's honest opinion. I think you phrased this in a way that doesn't discourage other people who may be sugar-free from trying them, and you gave your honest opinion. Everyone has different tastes and I glad to know that your palate didn't care for them, but at the same time I know about Yes! To Cookies and can share this brand with families who are both sugar and starch free. Thanks again! Tinsley

  • Tinsley – Thank you so much for your nice comment! :) I pride myself on being honest, so I couldn't have written anything but the truth here.


  • There is evidently a bunch to identify about this. I feel you made some good points in features also.

  • @TweetSmarter you any help with tweetdeck, keeps saying API can’t authenticate me but fine on twitter hmmmf

  • I really like your blog.. very nice colors & theme. Did you design this website yourself or did you hire someone to do it for you? Plz reply as I’m looking to create my own blog and would like to know where u got this from. many thanks

  • Thanks, for this great post. I look forward to reading more later. I think you are pretty knowledgeable in this particular area. If it is okay with you, I would like to repost this on my blog?

  • Amy

    I tried these today and was NOT impressed. Very expensive, with very little taste.I would have to say NO to these.

Leave a Reply